topcacabs

Top California Cabs. of the '90s, Tasting

As usual tasting will be held at my house.   Tasting will be limited to 14 persons.

  Time 2pm, Sat., October 13th.          

Preview, with ratings and current average prices.

  #1, 1996 Diamond Creek,"Volcanic Hill", ws-94 $175.   #2, 1994 Diamond Creek, "Red Rock Terrace", ws-91 $126. #3, 1997 Robert Mondavi Reserve, wa-92 $150.   #4,1994 Chateau Montelena, ws&wa-95 $170.   #5, 1995 Girard Reserve, ws-91 $85.   #6, 1999 Beringer Private Reserve, ws-91 $105.   #7, 1999 "V" Viader (Petite Verdot), ws-92 $104.   #8,1999 Freemark Abbey "Bosche", ws-91 $82.   #9, 1995 Freemark Abbey, Sycamore Vineyard, ws-89 $85.   #10, 1999 Grgich Hills, ws-91 $109.   #11, 1997 Sterling Reserve, ws-94 $100.   #12, 1994 Sterling, ws-89 $45.   #13, 1999 Mount Veeder Reserve, ws-92 $76.                                         Total over $1,460  

;

The 1997 Mondavi Reserve and the Sterling Reserve got very good reviews. The 1994 Sterling was over the hill. All the others were great.

My overall favorite was the 1994 Diamond Creek, "Red Rock Terrace".

The Diamond Creeks were the favorites.

Wine Spectator Napa 90's Vintage Chart

  • 1999 (97) Drink or hold Tremendous depth, concentration and structure from a cool, moderate year; ageworthy
  • 1998 (84) Past peak Cool, damp year with mostly green, herbal wines marked by gritty tannins; few memorable bottles
  • 1997 (99) Drink Huge crop of ripe, opulent, fleshy, concentrated wines, from near-perfect weather; super in Sonoma, too
  • 1996 (96) Drink A sleeper, with a remarkable number of compelling wines; warm year with fine concentration and depth
  • 1995 (97) Drink Surprisingly fine year, with wines marked by great flavors, balance and structure
  • 1994 (97) Drink A showy year all around; ripe, complex and fleshy, with excellent depth
  • 1993 (88) Drink Just off the pace, with well-balanced, supple wines; a few stars
  • 1992 (93) Drink Fine growing season led to uniformly rich, fleshy, supple and balanced wines
  • 1991 (91) Drink Big crop, ripe and complex; a star early on, only to be eclipsed by others this decade
  • 1990 (89) Drink Small crop but many deeply concentrated wines that have aged well

    We are featuring two wines from the legendary 1997 vintage (99). Five wines from the Classic 1999 vintage (97). Two wines from the Classic 1995 vintage (97). Three wines from the Classic 1994 vintage (97). One wine from the1996 vintage (96)